In order to dampen the effect a major policy decision of submission of CNICs, SAI strongly recommends that input tax inadmissibility should be made in stages giving time for the business community to adapt to the new rules.
Instead of disallowing proportionate input tax for sales made without CNICs, the following alternate is recommended:• Input tax inadmissible to the extent of 3% of sales made without CNIC till 30th September, 2019.• Input tax inadmissible to the extent of 5% of sales made without CNIC till 31st December, 2019.• Input tax inadmissible to the extent of 7.5% of sales made without CNIC till 30th June, 2020.
By gradually disallowing input as a percentage of sales will make the transition smooth. Moreover, it will bein line with the previous system of charging further tax of 3% of sales made to non filers, which will effectively be extended till 30th September but in an IMF compliant manner.
SAI believes in the documentation of the economy and that if a citizen can submit CNIC for purchasing a SIM card which is almost free then there is no reason to shy away from submitting CNIC for purchases above PKR 50,000/-. More than the requirement of CNIC, it is the sudden imposition of it that is one of the causes of the stiff resistance being faced by FBR.
A gradual and progressive implementation of the penalty on sales without CNIC will definitely make the whole process more palatable.